Skip to main content

Harnessing Repetitive Behaviours to Engage Attention and Learning in a Novel Therapy for Autism: An Exploratory Analysis

πŸ“„ Original study β†—
Chen, Grace Megumi, Yoder, Keith Jonathon, Ganzel, Barbara Lynn, Goodwin, Matthew S, Belmonte, Matthew Kenneth β€’ 2012 Modern Era β€’ methodology

πŸ“Œ Appears in:

Plain English Summary

This is the only published quantitative study of RPM (Rapid Prompting Method) -- a controversial therapy where a facilitator helps non-speaking autistic children communicate by pointing to letters. Researchers video-coded sessions with 9 kids and found repetitive behaviors decreased over time while children handled increasingly complex choices without stumbling. But here's the twist -- in 8 out of 9 kids, looking at the task was linked to worse performance, echoing other research questioning who's really driving the communication. Critically, the study never tested whether responses were genuinely the children's own, and every session was run by RPM's developer.

Actual Paper Abstract

Rigorous, quantitative examination of therapeutic techniques anecdotally reported to have been successful in people with autism who lack communicative speech will help guide basic science toward a more complete characterisation of the cognitive profile in this underserved subpopulation, and show the extent to which theories and results developed with the high-functioning subpopulation may apply. This study examines a novel therapy, the "Rapid Prompting Method" (RPM). RPM is a parent-developed communicative and educational therapy for persons with autism who do not speak or who have difficulty using speech communicatively. The technique aims to develop a means of interactive learning by pointing amongst multiple-choice options presented at different locations in space, with the aid of sensory "prompts" which evoke a response without cueing any specific response option. The prompts are meant to draw and to maintain attention to the communicative task – making the communicative and educational content coincident with the most physically salient, attention-capturing stimulus – and to extinguish the sensory–motor preoccupations with which the prompts compete. Video-recorded RPM sessions with nine autistic children ages 8–14 years who lacked functional communicative speech were coded for behaviours of interest. An analysis controlled for age indicates that exposure to the claimed therapy appears to support a decrease in repetitive behaviours and an increase in the number of multiple-choice response options without any decrease in successful responding. Direct gaze is not related to successful responding, suggesting that direct gaze might not be any advantage for this population and need not in all cases be a precondition to communication therapies.

Research Notes

The only peer-reviewed quantitative behavioural analysis of RPM, the method underlying the Telepathy Tapes controversy. The negative gaze-success relationship echoes jaswal_2019_being_appearing. Key limitation: all sessions conducted by the method's developer. Belongs in folder 11 as empirical background for the RPM/FC debate.

Video-coded analysis of RPM (Rapid Prompting Method) therapy sessions with 9 non-speaking autistic children (ages 8-14, CARS 42.5-50). Coders blind to session order rated middle 10-minute segments of sessions 1, 2, 4, and 8 for repetitive/stereotypic behaviours, gaze, response rate, choice complexity, and prompting. Mixed-effects model controlling for age found RSB incidence declined across sessions (b=-0.011, p=0.045). Direct gaze was negatively correlated with task success in 8/9 subjects. Therapist prompt rate strongly predicted response rate (b=0.480, p=0.00004). Choice complexity increased across sessions while success rate did not decline. Validity of communications was explicitly not tested.

Links

Related Papers

More in Methodology

πŸ“‹ Cite this paper
APA
Chen, Grace Megumi, Yoder, Keith Jonathon, Ganzel, Barbara Lynn, Goodwin, Matthew S, Belmonte, Matthew Kenneth (2012). Harnessing Repetitive Behaviours to Engage Attention and Learning in a Novel Therapy for Autism: An Exploratory Analysis. Frontiers in Psychology. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2012.00012
BibTeX
@article{chen_2012_nonverbal_autism,
  title = {Harnessing Repetitive Behaviours to Engage Attention and Learning in a Novel Therapy for Autism: An Exploratory Analysis},
  author = {Chen, Grace Megumi and Yoder, Keith Jonathon and Ganzel, Barbara Lynn and Goodwin, Matthew S and Belmonte, Matthew Kenneth},
  year = {2012},
  journal = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2012.00012},
}